After a few days, however, the dreaded "USB device not recognised" error appeared.
I tried all the solutions online:
- Turn computer power off at the wall
- Uninstall USB drivers
- Set USB sleep timer to never
I went to http://www.uwe-sieber.de/usbdlm_e.html and downloaded the USB Drive Letter Manager and edited the ini file to manually force the USB drives to the letter I specified.
It worked! I haven't had any issues since.